Eight habits of the players who keep ending up on top of the leaderboard
Custom captions score an extra point when they win, and they win far more often than dealt cards — because a card written for a thousand GIFs can never be as sharp as one written for this GIF, in this room, for these people. Here's what separates the captions that get votes from the ones that get polite silence.
Everyone can see the cat falling off the shelf. A caption that says "cat falls off shelf" adds nothing. A caption that says "me realising the meeting was at 9, not 10" gives the picture a story. The GIF is the punchline; your job is the setup. Ask yourself: what situation would make a person look exactly like that?
"When you're late" is fine. "When you're late and the bus driver makes eye contact and pulls away anyway" is a vote. Details — a named object, an exact number, a recognisable moment — turn a generic joke into one that feels observed. The best captions sound like something that actually happened to someone.
You're not writing for the internet, you're writing for the six people in your lobby. A reference to your friend's terrible parking, the group chat's running joke, or whatever happened on the drive over will beat a cleverer but anonymous line every time. Private rooms are where inside jokes shine; in public rooms with strangers, aim for universal experiences — work, family, food, phones.
GIFs loop, and most have a beat: a pause, a turn, a reaction. Match your caption to that beat. A slow build ("watching the thermostat war unfold between my parents…") suits a GIF where the reaction lands late; a short blunt caption ("no.") suits an instant reaction. If the GIF has two characters, decide which one you're captioning — "the other guy" is often the funnier choice.
Voters read every caption in under thirty seconds. Long captions get skimmed and skimmed captions don't get votes. Cut every word that isn't earning its place. If you can say it in eight words, don't use fifteen. The exception is the deliberately over-specific caption (see tip 2), where the length is the joke — but even then, keep the run-on to one breath.
"Me when" and "when you" are the default shape for a GIF caption, and they work. But when five captions in a row start the same way, the one that doesn't stands out. Try a quote ("'I'm fine.' — me, not fine"), a fake headline, a text message, or a single word. Variety gets attention, and attention gets votes.
Something funny happened in round two? Bring it back in round five — the final round, when points are doubled. A caption that references an earlier winning caption, a chat message, or the fact that Dave hasn't won anything yet rewards everyone who's been paying attention. Callbacks feel like a shared secret, and people vote for what makes them feel included.
Half-hearted captions are obvious. If the joke is that the GIF looks like your dad at a barbecue, say "my dad at a barbecue after someone suggests he might be flipping too early", not "dad at bbq lol". Don't hedge with "kind of" or "basically". Voters back confidence.
Dealt cards are the safety net. Play one when the timer's nearly out and you've got nothing, or when a card in your hand is a genuinely perfect match — it happens, and a perfect card still earns the winner bonus. But if you're choosing between a decent card and a decent custom caption, write the caption. The extra point adds up over a game, and the practice makes you better.
Now go and test the theory: start a game. If you're new, the full rules take two minutes to read.
Subscribe for news on features, content, and general updates on the game. We promise no more than 2 emails per month and to never sell your information to a 3rd party.
